I’ve known quite a few writers who feel like outlining their short story or novel is the best and more efferent way to get their writing done. Often they also like to do character sketches either before or during the writing process because they feel like this helps them to fully understand their protagonists and secondary characters. Many of writing books and websites also say the same thing, some even go so far as to say this is the way it “should” be done.
This method has never worked for me however. I’ve tried to start with an outline and character sketches, but one of two things always ends up happening. Either I already know the ending so it’s not as intriguing for me to write, and I have trouble getting from point A to point B, or more commonly, the characters do not do what I tell them to. Yes, my characters have minds of their own. And they don’t like it when I tell them they are supposed to act a certain way or do a specific thing. They end up coming to life, and I find that when I try to make them stick to what I have planned they end up coming out very flat, and not rounded as they should be.
Yes, my name is Val, and I hear voices when I write.
On the serious side, I rarely know what is going to happen further than a scene or two ahead in the piece I am working on. This does make for some odd kinks in the story sometimes, sometimes things I write won’t make sense in the context of the finished work, but I don’t edit as I write the rough draft; but that is where revising comes in.
For instance, the novel I am currently revising, working title Moving on Nightfall, started with an image. I have over my net travels read about people who live in abandoned subway stations, and one day I was trying to think of a story starter, and someone said something about subways, and said, That’s it! So I started with this image of an abandoned subway station, with some light coming is from a glassed-in panel in the ceiling, and a little nest made of discarded items. My protagonist is a girl named Jenny, and from the beginning I knew that while she was street smart, she had also been beaten on by life, and tended to retreat into herself when she didn’t know how to control what was going on around her. And there was another character who shared the station, a crazy old alcoholic vet named Sunny who sees himself as her protector. As I started to write it I learned about the characters as I got into it, and they grew more real and round. Jenny works as a prostitute, she does art, she’s a transsexual, and she still has a touch of naïvety about her. Sunny is big and gruff and obnoxious, but accepts Jenny for who she is, and heaven help anyone he catches messing with her.
While I started out with the story I had no idea where it was going to go. I was thinking it might have a fantasy twist, and it did turn out to be an urban fantasy. But while the main concept of the story stayed the same, many of the details of how it worked shifted several times throughout the writing of the novel. So on the revision, now that I completely understand how the story works, I am going back and editing details so the whole story works together, sometimes rewriting scenes.
I have a lot more to say on this, but I’ll start with this overview, and go further into details in other posts. I also plan on talking more about Moving on Nightfall.